TRADE PRACTICES

 

 

December 2009

Unfair contract legislation delayed

In previous newsletters we have described the proposed new national unfair contract laws. These will render any 'unfair' term in a standard form consumer contract void. This has substantial implications for a huge range of contracts, from property developers' off the plan contracts, to software licences, through to the standard terms and conditions used by any company that supplies products direct to consumers.

 

The Federal Government previously stated that these laws would come into effect on 1 January. Partly as a result of the ETS wranglings, the relevant Bill (the Trade Practices Amendments (Australian Consumer Law Bill) 2009) was not passed by the Senate in its most recent sittings. Since there are no more parliamentary sittings this year, the earliest the Bill can now pass is February next year. 

 

The draft Bill has now been amended to provide that the new unfair contract laws will not come into effect until at least 1 July 2010.

 

Other changes made to the draft Bill include the following:

§         A consumer will now not be able to challenge an unfair term unless he or she can show that enforcement of the term would cause them actual detriment. This detriment can be non-financial (eg, mere irritation or distress to the consumer of any type may suffice), so the change may not result in a significant narrowing of the effect of the new laws.

§         Contracts entered into prior to 1 July 2010 will be exempt from the new rules. If any term of that contract is varied after 1 July 2010, only that provision becomes subject to the new rules. Previously, if any provision of a contract was varied the whole contract would become subject to the new unfair contract rules. 

 

Senator Xenophon has proposed his own amendments to the Bill to apply the unfair contract rules to business to business contracts and insurance contracts. The likelihood of Senator Xenophon's proposals being adopted, however, seems low.

 

Other Australian Consumer Law reforms

The Federal Government announced on Friday last week that the Ministerial Council on Consumer Affairs (MCCA - a committee of State and Federal Consumer Affairs Ministers) had agreed the substance of further Australian Consumer Law reforms. As with the unfair contract rules, the new laws will be added as a schedule to the Trade Practices Act which will then be adopted by each of the States by the end of next year to apply as State law as well as Federal. 

 

Significant recommendations include the following:

§         The system of implied consumer warranties will be rewritten. The rewrite looks likely to be based on New Zealand's Consumer Guarantees Act. This, in substance, is largely a plain English version of the existing TPA provisions. For example, the current "warranty of merchantable quality" becomes a "guarantee of acceptable quality". When consumers can claim a refund and how they can claim refunds will also be rewritten.

§         Product safety and recall laws will be rewritten. Suppliers will have a legal obligation to report when they become aware that a product has been associated with serious injury or death.

§         The various state laws on unsolicited sales (eg, door to door sales and telephone sales) will be standardised. For example, this will mean standardised rules on disclosures and whether or not cooling off periods will apply to such sales.

If you have any questions, please contact one of our partners named below.

 

 

 

Richard Westmoreland

Robert Gardini

Peter van Rompaey

 

(02) 9334 8717

(02) 9334 8619

(03) 8633 7506

 

 

 

 

 

Steve Burns

Simon Tolhurst

 

 

(02) 9334 8841

(07) 3002 6749

 

 

 

 

If you do not wish to receive further e-Alerts from our Commercial Group, please reply ‘remove’ to this email.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Brisbane | Melbourne | Norwest | Sydney

hwlebsworth.com.au